Or can we???? http://www.frumsatire.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/RosietheTefillinWearer.jpg |
Once this pressure went away however, I still felt something unhinging inside me, creeping up, an old friend. I was at a school Shabbaton sitting with a small group of friends and rabbis. I asked them their thoughts on Shelo Asani Isha ("Thank you G-d for not making me a woman). There was some apologism, but mostly answers I expected. The talk turned to the female exemption from positive timebound mitzvot. I began to cry, I debated with the rabbis, each respectful and even in awe that a teenager cared so much about religion. After that session I realized what I've really been struggling with all throughout Tefillingate, and in general, regarding liberal Judaism and complete egalitarianism.
http://afflictor.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/IMG_8352.JPG.jpeg |
Ritually treated as someone with nothing to add, my only realms of control are sex and children, rich realms, to be sure, but not highly communal, visible or commended ones. I crave to lead, to lay, to leyn, and to learn. I am an important part of the Jewish people, not just someone's mother, but rather the next generation of Chazal, poskim, respected leaders. As someone so passionately committed to Halachic Judaism, I feel betrayed by the frum community's awkward sweeping aside of my leadership and care.
However, this passion is its own prison. Whenever I've been to fully egalitarian, liberal Jewish spaces, I feel that everything is a bit too casual, too new, too fluid. It doesn't feel legitimate to me (NOT that it isn't, just that it doesn't feel that way to me, personally). I want to be respected by Orthodox rabbis, I want Partnership minyanim to be considered fully Halachic, because that is where I feel safe. I don't want Neo- Halacha, I want old Halacha supporting the things that bring me spiritual fulfillment. I want my voice valued, and contrary to my usual prerogative, I want to be normative. Not in the eyes of society, but in the eyes of G-d.
So who knows if I will end up wearing tefillin (call me in 5- 10 years). But before I decide, I have something to say. To me, this Tefillingate is not about tefillin, or even chiuv(that's for another post...). It's about weighing citizenship with legitimacy. I'm not 100% sure of the Halachic support or leniency for women laying tefillin, but, I do think that dissenters harm the Jewish people by alienating the women who care most. The women who think critically, worship devotedly and experiment with new ways of achieving intimacy with G-d. For if these strong, beautiful women have their spirits broken, all is lost.
Love,
Helyn